Skip to main content

ANTH 628

New World Seafaring Anthropology

Dr. Kevin Crisman

Office hours: W, 10 a.m. – 12 p.m.
Location: ANTH 131b (inside the New World Seafaring Lab)
Email: kcrisman@tamu.edu
Phone: 979-492-0751

Course Description

This course combines archaeological and historical sources to examine the development of shipbuilding, seafaring practices, exploration, waterborne trade and economic systems, and naval warfare in the Western Hemisphere (the Americas) from the fifteenth century to the beginning of the twentieth century. Particular emphasis is given to the study of shipwrecks that illuminate change and continuity in the maritime sphere.

Course Requirements

Seminar Presentations and Discussions (50% of final grade).

During the semester each student will be assigned several topics to research and present in class. Presentations should be about 40-45 minutes in length to leave some time for discussion. Please prepare and distribute a bibliography of the sources consulted for your seminar presentation. Use of visual aids such as Powerpoint™ projections, interpretive dances, and declamatory arm waving is strongly encouraged.

Seminar presentations will be graded on the basis of their thoroughness, organization, and clarity, as well as the quality of illustrations (where appropriate) and the distribution of a bibliography of the sources consulted in preparing the presentation.

 

Term Paper (50% of final grade).

In addition, each student is to conduct research on some aspect of New World seafaring and prepare a professional, publishable-quality term paper on the subject. The first step, after selecting a topic and researching sources, will be to prepare a three page term paper proposal modeled on a thesis proposal; in the proposal you will state the nature and importance of the topic, discuss previous research and potential sources, outline your plan for analysis of the data, and summarize the significance of the proposed research. A bibliography of primary and secondary sources that you intend to use in preparing the term paper must be included. The term paper proposal is due on Week 3.

The term paper should be in the range of 15 to 25 pages in length (12-point font, double spaced); 20 pages is generally a good length. Be sure the paper follows the requirements provided in my “Guidelines for Writing Your Term Paper” handout. The paper is to be submitted on or before Week 15. Submitting your paper after this date will likely result in a lower grade.

My paper grading criteria are as follows: (“A”) research, analysis, writing, and citation are professional and with minimal editing the paper could be published as a journal article or book chapter; (“B”) paper is good in most respects, but due to shortcomings in one or more areas would require significant editing before publication would be possible; (“C”) paper is at lowest levels of acceptability, and would require major new research or re-writing to achieve publishable standards; (“D”) paper falls below lowest levels of acceptability in research, analysis, writing, and citation; (“F”) paper fails to meet all professional standards, or the professor has found evidence of plagiarism, or the assignment was never completed.

Please note: I read term papers carefully, which means I read them slowly. It is possible that I may not be able to read your paper and grade it before the deadline to turn in grades; if this occurs you will receive a temporary “Incomplete” until the paper is graded and I can submit a “Change of Grade” form. Do not be alarmed by an “Incomplete” unless you failed to turn in your paper. If you need to get the final grade on your transcript to meet a deadline (for job or graduate school applications, for example), let me know.

Readings

George F. Bass, ed.  Ships and Shipwrecks of the Americas.  London: Thames and Hudson, 1988. Copies of this book are on reserve in the Nautical Library. Other short readings are listed on the syllabus, and copies of those books or off-prints will be placed on NAP Library reserve.

Course Schedule:

(The schedule is a subject to change, revisions, and refinements which will be posted)

Week 1 Introduction
  • Course requirements
  • Suggestions for seminar presentations
  • Preparing a successful term paper
  • Distribution of seminar topics 
Week 2 European Exploration and Colonization of the Western Hemisphere. 

Reading:  Bass, ed., Chapters 1-4. 

Lecture: “The Enterprise of the Indies”: Spain, Columbus and the New World. 

Seminar topics:

  1. Anonymous Explorers: The Molasses Reef and Highborn Cay Wrecks.
  2. Basque Whalers in the New World: The San Juan and Red Bay, Labrador. 
Week 3 The Spanish Seaborne Empire in the Seventeenth Century.

Reading:  Bass, ed., Chapter 5. 

Lecture: The Administration and Defense of Spain’s New World Empire. 

Seminar topics: 

  1. Spanish losses in the Gulf of Mexico: The Padre Island and Emanuel Point Wrecks.
  2. The Manilla Galleons: San Felipe (1576), San Diego (1600) and Concepción (1638). 
Term paper proposal and bibliography due
Week 4 Northern European Colonization and Trade

Reading:  Bass, ed., Chapter 6 

Lecture: The English, French, and Dutch in the New World. 

Seminar topics: 

  • Bermuda’s Tempest Wrecks: The English Galleons Sea Venture (1609) and Warwick (1619).
  • Texas Death Trip: La Selle's Belle (1686).
Week 5 Anglo-French Conflicts in the Americas.

Reading: Bass, ed., Chapter 7. 

Lecture: War in the Wilderness: The Struggle for the North American Continent. 

Seminar topics:

  1. Scuttled in the Restigouche: The Frigate Machault (1760).
  2. Jeffery Amherst’s Lake Sloop Boscawen (1759). [Crisman
Week 6 Naval Aspects of the Revolutionary War. 

Reading: Bass, ed., Chapter 8. 

Lecture: A Synopsis of American and British Naval Activity, 1775-1783. 

Seminar topics:

  1. American Naval Debacle, 1779: Defence and other Penobscot Wrecks.
  2. British Military Debacle, 1781: Betsy and other Yorktown Wrecks. 
Week 7 Freshwater Fleets: The Naval War of 1812.

Reading: Bass, ed., Chapter 9. 

Lecture: A Synopsis of the War of 1812 on the Oceans and Lakes. 

Seminar topics:

  1. Fore-and-Afters at Fifty Fathoms: The Armed Merchant Schooners Hamilton and Scourge (1813).
  2. U.S. Navy Lake Brigs: Niagara, Eagle, and Jefferson (1813-1814). [Crisman
Week 8 Inland Waters I: Canals and Ferries.

Reading: Shaw, Ronald. Canals for a Nation. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1990.
Read Ch. 1-2, 6-7, others if time. On reserve in NAP Library. 

Lecture: Clinton’s Big Ditch: The History and Engineering of the Erie Canal. 

Seminar topics:

  1. The Design, Construction, and Operation of Canal Boats (including the Sailing Canal Boats of Lake Champlain).
  2. Horse-powered Ferries. [Crisman
Week 9 Inland Waters II: Steam on Lakes and Rivers

Reading:  Bass, ed., Chapter 10.

Marestier, Jean Baptiste. Memoir on Steamboats of the United States of America. Mystic,  Connecticut: The Marine Historical Association, Inc., 1957. On Reserve in the Nautical Library.  

Twain, Mark.  Life on the Mississippi. New York: Harper and Row, 1965. Chapters I-XX photocopied and on reserve in the Nautical Library. 

Lecture: Brief Remarks on the Impact of Steam Propulsion on American Society. 

Seminar topics:

  1. Early Steamers: Phoenix I, Phoenix II, and Lady Sherbrooke.
  2. Western River Steamboats and the Sidewheeler Heroine. [Crisman]
  3. Great Lakes Steamers and Steamer Wrecks: the Sidewheelers Anthony Wayne, Niagara, and Propeller Indiana
Week 10 The Golden Age of Sail in the United States, 1815-1860.

Reading:  Bass, ed., Chapter 12. 

Lecture: Brief Remarks on North America’s Era of Maritime Enterprise. 

Seminar topics:

  1. Quest for Speed: Baltimore Clippers, Packets, and the Great Clippers.
  2. Sail’s Rising Competitor: North Atlantic Steamships, 1819-1860
  3. The Charles W. Morgan and American Whaling. 
Week 11 Doomed Polar Expedition/American Civil War.

Reading: Bass, ed., Chapter 11. 

Lecture: Old and New Technologies: The Navies of the Civil War.

Seminar topics:

  1. The Loss and Discovery of Franklin’s Erebus and Terror
  2. The Union Ironclads Monitor and Cairo.   
Week 12 The Civil War, Part II

Seminar topics:

  1. Despoiler of the Union Merchant Fleet: The Confederate Raider Alabama.
  2. The Denbigh and Other Confederate Blockade Runners
  3. Iron Coffins: Hunley and Other Civil-War-Era Submarines 
Week 13 Out with the Old, In with the New: Wood to Iron, Canvas to Steam. 

Reading: Skip it this week, work on your term paper instead. 

Lecture: Brief Remarks on the End of the Age of Sail. 

Seminar topics:

  • Twilight of Commercial Sail: Down Easters and Merchant Schooners.
  • Marine Paintings and the Nautical Archaeologist. [Crisman
Week 14 Presentation of Term Paper Research